Author Archives: RomanInUkraine

Why did Putin Invade? (short and long perspectives)

Why did Putin invade?

Short perspective — the spectacle of people self-organizing to overthrow a corrupt, brutal, abusive regime is terrifying to his own corrupt, brutal, abusive regime.

Long perspective — the idea of a “Russian” people is an artificial concept (at least in its expansionist incarnation) and an 18th century idea, just like the idea of an “American” people. But the “great brotherhood” that is the Russian myth gets exposed for the lie it is by the assertion of Ukrainian identity — something Ukrainians have been struggling for for centuries. It’s evident in our poetry: “What are these Muskovites looking for in our torn open graves? Our past glory? An ancient parent? If they could only find one, our children wouldn’t be crying.”

The Drunks and Vagrants who call themselves “Euromaidan” arrested after big confrontation in Kiev. (VICE)

VICE overstates this. Almost nobody in Ukraine still considers the people on maidan legitimate. They’re thugs, drunks and vagrants. This view was actually seconded by my taxi driver a couple days ago when this story came over the radio. The cab driver added that he’d been on maidan himself when it was necessary.

Curt on Ukrainian incompetence

Haven’t made a “wasteland” post in a while.

So, I go to pick up my laptop. They run the charge through the card reader three times and they get an error code each time. They call me today and say they have it fixed. I show up. It doesn’t work. I find out that they have charged me 12K because each transaction DID process, and is now being refunded.

I think we need to have refunds on errors issued immediately, with the merchant absorbing the risk. Where the hell is our consumer protection?

So I am out 12K, albeit for three days, and I have no new laptop [technical problem with it]. Sigh.

This kind of incompetence is rife here.

Sh_t doesn’t work. It doesn’t work. Anywhere. It’s exasperating.

So yes, the people are wonderful, and yes, it’s beautiful and yes the food is good, and yes it’s inexpensive. But you have to put up with third world infrastructure and the all too pervasive remains of soviet bureaucratic incompetence – everywhere.

Four anecdotes about the effectiveness of Russian Propaganda

1. Starting in January, I heard stories from friends with relatives in Russia. Their relatives would call and ask whether it was true that people in Lviv were beaten in the streets for speaking Russian.

Ridiculous. There is even a Russian street musician. (Perhaps he’s paid by the FSB to Russify Lviv.)

2. Another friend who works in a hostel told me a Russian family stayed there for a week, barely leaving their room except to the grocery store because, she later discovered, they feared Ukrainian fascists would attack them. These accounts are so divorced from reality, I wouldn’t believe them if they weren’t first-hand accounts.

3. A close friend of mine has relatives from Donbass. It was either an immediate aunt, or a sibling of a grand parent who moved there and had a family.

Now, the decedent’s daughter has returned to Lviv, her ancestral home, as a refugee. She fled with husband and children. My friend’s family helped them get settled.

She too was SCARED to speak Russian despite assurances from her hosts. Later, their daughters were playing together — two little children. Eventually, the refugee child from Donbas started speaking Ukrainian, and her mother, right in front of everybody, told her not to use that Khokhol language.

“Khokhol” is an insulting word Russians use for Ukrainian people. Apparently, her hosts had enough at that point, and told her pretty angrily what an ungrateful, Russian-zombified bitch she was being. Her behavior improved.

4. If you look through the videos I posted here and elsewhere, you’ll encounter raw footage of Russian mercenaries who believe they are fight Poles, Czechs, Blackwater, American military, Abrams tanks, Apache helicopters. These people are f-ing idiots. It’s be funny if it wasn’t so dangerous.

Curt on Refugees in Lviv

In Lviv, the people with bad manners, and act like they grew up in trailer parks, speak Russian, not Ukrainian. The propagandized disenfranchised and displaced have moved east [west]. Sort of like how the people of Louisiana ruined cities in Texas.

Good deeds never go unpunished.

Facts Vs Opinions (from a Youtube discussion where I was accused of being biased)

FACTS VS OPINIONS
The Maidan protests were never Nazi or Fascist. Russia’s mercenary leaders have been members of explicitly Nazi organizations and use explicit Nazi symbols.
The Maidan protests never threatened Jews. (Three Jewish Ukrainian were killed protesting on Maidan.)
The Maidan protests and the new government never threatened Russians. Russians also protested on Maidan.
Pro Russian protests in the east were never assaulted.
Pro Ukrainian protests were viciously assaulted in Kharkiv, Donetsk, Luhansk, Crimea by hooligans imported from Russia — imported hooligans were used in Tallinn Estonia in 2009 when Estonians relocated (not even fully removed!) a statue to the Soviet “liberators,” who after “liberation” deported 17% of the Estonian population to Siberia.
Only the Russians have used torture. Only the Russians have systemically kidnapped journalists.
There is no “ethnic cleansing” of Russian speakers as Daniel McAdams claims. Half the fucking Ukrainian military speaks Russian. The closest thing to ethnic cleansing is the Russian terror / intimidation campaigns in Crimea and the east.
Russia did indeed invade Crimea (contrary to McAdam’s claims).
Russia is indeed supplying the mercenaries in the east (contrary to McAdam’s claims).
No Russian books have been burned. The Russians have staged Ukrainian book burnings.
While Russia’s professional provocateurs imagine and advertize hatred toward Russians in Ukraine (and Finland, Estonia, Lativa, Lituania, Belarus, Khazakstan, Georgia), little of it exist. On the other hand, within Russia itself, Ukrainian language story books even get removed from libraries.
Politifact concluded that statements by Paul Crag Roberts and others that the US spent $5 Billion overthrowing Ukraine’s government are gross distortions.

These are facts. I am also biased. But the above thing are facts. Here are my opinions:

Ukraine is a culture trying to defend itself by establish a state. Russia is a state trying to find legitimacy by enforcing a uniform culture (ie obliterating the local cultures of conquered peoples).

Russia is a fake people and a fake culture. Czar Peter I of Muskovy gave the name “Russian” too all the diverse people he conquered — slavs, Turkiks, Tartars, Asians, Finno Ugrics. The stole the legacy Kievan Rus which was located in Ukraine 300 before Moscow even existed.

So Czar Peter stole the name for his conquered people from Ukraine, and he stole the flag from Holland, where he studied.

He, and subsequent “Russian” leaders have had to aggressive edit history, destroying, editing, hiding ancient cronicals to create a single polity. It has been failing miserably for 200 years, which is why they’ve needed to murder all those millions of people, but that doesn’t work either.

Russia’s main exports are tyranny and misery. Kim Il Sung, Mao, Castro — all trained in Russia.

Prosecutor General to explore bureaucratic stasis. No $$ to ATO despite allocation.

The Prosecutor General’s Office reported that officials are investigating the enchanting slowness of the Defense Ministry officials regarding the procurement of equipment for the military–for both the budgetary costs, and the donation funds received from citizens.

Frankly, in recent months we have heard a million explanations why a budget of billions, allocated for the ATO, is sitting motionless in the accounts and not moving, as well as an essential part of the charitable duties. And at this time we only see a shortage in the [military] units–in one, then another, or a third.

http://maidantranslations.com/2014/08/06/dmitry-tymchuks-military-blog-summary-august-5-2014/